Thursday, January 28, 2010

PSC 341 Machiavelli's Gentlemen

Machiavelli writes that gentlemen are germs of corruption, and the causes of every possible immorality. Gentlemen in Machiavelli's words "live in luxury with out working...have a castle with subjects". I wouldn't say that gentlemen in Machiavelli's sense are dangerous to society in a ambiguous sense, but a republic based society. He states that since the "gentlemen are so corrupt that laws will not restrain them", the only political system sufficient enough to control them would be a monarchy, so that it would be swift, and decisive with absolute power. Because gentlemen are above the laws, a republic, where the aristocracy, monarchs, and the people all have a voice, that political system would not work, as the gentlemen have much wealth. The only way to have a republic is by not having that social caste of individual inside of its limits, so effectively one would have to eradicate that threat from the influence area of the republic.

1 comment:

Prof. Hersch said...

Matt,

Good job overall. You needed to say just a bit more about why gentlemen (according to Mach) can't be restrained by law. Also I needed a sentence or two of your own view (or a contemporary application)

2

Also, please remember only one blog post per week.